Tobey Maguire’sSpider - Mancould come along inAvengers : Secret Wars , but his possible return can not plainly be that . Maguire first appeared as the Web - Slinger in 2002’sSpider - valet de chambre , which not only became a massive strike but also fully birth the advanced superhero movie craze . Maguire return as Peter inSpider - Man 2andSpider - Man 3 , but his wall - crawling Clarence Shepard Day Jr. seemed to be over when Sony rebooted Spidey on film with 2012’sThe Amazing Spider - Man . However , that changed with the 2021 mega - hitSpider - piece : No Way Home .

The multiverse - based plot ofNo Way Homebrought Maguire ’s Spider - Man together on - screen with Andrew Garfield ’s and Tom Holland ’s and sparked massive exuberance for further risky venture with both Maguire and Garfield . Maguire has show receptivity for more Spider - Man , amid speculation that he might be set to devolve again in Marvel ’s upcomingAvengers : private Wars . While such an appearance by Maguire would be an exciting medical prognosis , it also would be a limiting one . Here is why , if Tobey Maguire is to continue as Peter Parker , Spider - Man 4is as necessary to his story as an appearance inSecret Wars .

Maguire’s Peter Parker’s Life Post-Spider-Man 3 Life Is Unexplored

WhileNo Way Homerevealed a average amount about Andrew Garfield ’s Peter Parker being " rageful " and " bitter " afterThe Amazing Spider - Man 2 , the life of Maguire ’s Peter afterSpider - Man 3was keep much more shrouded , per Tobey Maguire ’s own request . No style Homefocusing on Hollandwas ultimately the right call for the movie , which impart an aura of mystery to Maguire ’s Peter # 2 by only revealing that he and Mary Jane ( Kirsten Dunst ) had have a rough patch and had patched things up . This also allow what is effectively a blank slating for what Peter # 2 ’s post - Spider - Man 3life was like .

WithNo manner Homebecoming one of the braggart box office dispatch in history ( and the first $ 1 billion winner of the COVID era , no less ) , the inflammation for more of Maguire and Garfield ’s Spideys give each an extremely unique comeback chance . The fact that Maguire ’s Spider - Man has so much unexplored also leaves any protraction with him with fewer built - in expectations thanThe Amazing Spider - Man 3with Andrew Garfieldwould . In effect , the once abandonedSpider - Man 4has potentially more life post - No Way Homethan it did in the immediate consequence ofSpider - Man 3 .

Secret Wars May Not Do Full Justice To Maguire’s Spider-Man

With the MCU open up Marvel ’s multiverse throughSpider - Man : No Way HomeandDoctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness , the possibilities for pre - MCU ace to return to the Marvel plication are rapidly expanding . Multiverse of Madnessalready showed that with Patrick Stewart ’s return as Professor Charles Xavier , while Hugh Jackman is return as Wolverine inDeadpool 3 . Meanwhile , meditation is running high that Maguire and Garfield ’s Spider - Men may riposte forAvengers : Secret Wars , but the former might not get his full due by such an appearing .

WhileNo Way Homere - invigorate Andrew Garfield ’s Spider - Man , Maguire ’s did not take a hop in the same way because he did not ask to ( the approximative reception ofSpider - Man 3notwithstanding . ) Because of that , Maguire lack any kind of interim level before a potentialSecret Warsappearance would shortchange him considerably , even leave his appearance possibly feeling like a return for its own sake . The revival of Maguire’sSpider - Man 4can change that .

Maguire Spider-Man 4 Needs Happen (Even If He’s In Secret Wars)

With Maguire ’s Spider - Man given a major comeback inNo Way Home , Spider - Man 4exemplifies the potential drop of multiversal storytelling with the version of the Wall Crawler who started it all on the self-aggrandizing screen . Like Peter # 1 and Peter # 3 , Peter # 2 is a changed adult male bythe ending ofNo Way Home , but even more so by being the old , most experienced Spider - Man of the three . Not only is his past betweenSpider - valet 3andNo Way Homeripe to be turn over into , but so is his life after the latter film , due to Peter # 2 being a highly seasoned Spider - Man .

ASpider - Man 4with Maguire could have the genuine whatsis of being the Web - Slinger ’s response toLogan , showing an sr. interpretation of a dear Italian sandwich on one last adventure . As Hugh Jackman’sDeadpool 3return shows , " one last sentence " can still be technically reliable by excluding squad - ups or ensemble from that promise . The same could telephone reliable withTobey Maguire ’s Spider - Manreturning inSpider - Man 4 , the plastic film act as one final solo chapter of hisSpider - Manstory but leaving the door open for him to swing into natural action for the large battle ofAvengers : Secret Wars .

NEXT : Maguire ’s Spider - Man Might Have Prevented Ned ’s Worst Hobgoblin Fate

Spider-Man Noir

Josh Hartnett looking shocked in Fight or Flight

Chronicle Ending Explained - How Andrew Is Stopped In The Superhero Movie

Tobey Maguire in Spider-Man No Way Home pic

Tobey Maguire as Spider-Man looking sad in Spider-Man 3

Tobey Maguire as Peter Parker aiming his web in Spider-Man

Tobey Maguire speaks to Otto Octavius in Spider-Man: No Way Home.