Star Trek Beyond
One minor plot hole inStar Trek Beyondwas in the first place go to be unsex by adding a subtle reference toStar Trek II : The Wrath of Khan . J.J. Abrams’sStar Trekreboot is separate from the Prime Universe , with the event of its movies taking place in an alternating timeline known as the Kelvin Timeline . This has allowed for movies that are n’t constrained by decades of canyon and the restriction that go along with it , and for the most part , it has allowed for satisfyingStar Trekstories that are easily approachable to a all-encompassing consultation .
However , that does n’t make themovies ofStar Trek ’s Kelvin Timelineimpervious to plat holes and incompatibility . One such effect arises inStar Trek Beyond , wherein a substantial character from the late pic , Star Trek Into Darkness , but disappear without a trace . None ofStar TrekBeyond ’s characters mention her absence either , making it seem as though the Kelvin Timeline ’s Carol Marcus has been entirely forgotten between the two movies . Marcus was not only a central persona inStar Trek Into Darknessbut also inStar Trek II : The Wrath of Khan , in which she is the lead scientist on Project Genesis and the mother of James T. Kirk ’s only son .
relate : Star Trek Into Darkness ' Chekov Trick Is A Perfect TOS Reference
As well as playing Montgomery Scott in the Kelvin Timeline , Simon Pegg co - wroteStar Trek Beyond , and he revealed that there was to begin with a line in the film ’s book that referenced Carol Marcus ' absence . The blood would have drawn a parallel betweenStar Trek ’s Kelvin Timeline and the Prime Universeby revealing that Marcus had gone to work on Project Genesis . Had the line been used , it would have not only referencedWrath of Khanbut also would have specify up a perfect chance to explore the differences between the two timelines .
Star Trek Beyond’s Cut Wrath Of Khan Reference Would Have Been Perfect
Using the rail line about the Genesis Project would have served as the perfect curing - up for a future Kelvin Timeline movie in which the Genesis gadget is a patch constituent . However , the nature of the alternative timeline and the fact that Khan has already been encountered ( and imprisoned ) could make that tale very different fromThe Wrath of Khan , which could have been used as a means of well showcasing the departure betweenStar Trek ’s timeline in an constitutive way . In add-on , the use ofWrath of Khan ’s Genesis Devicewould raise the stake to the appropriate scourge level to constitute a feature - length story .
Pegg ’s intend explanation for Carol Marcus ' absence is also perfect in another sense . Not only would it have work well from a narrative point of view , but it also would have show the level of cognition and fear being put into the writing of the Kelvin Timeline ’s films , too . By cite a detail from one of the most belovedStar Trekmovies , Star Trek Beyondwould have contained yet another minor but significant connection to the Prime Universe , and it would have served as a subtly excellent moment of buff armed service .
Ultimately , it was adjudicate thatexplaining Carol Marcus ' absence inStar Trek Beyondwas not a topic of corking grandness . The grapheme was n’t entirely relevant to the third celluloid ’s plot of ground , but her induction into the endeavour ’s bunch should have facilitate even a minor appearance ( or at least a passing mention ) . However , the idea to fix the minor plot hole by cite the Genesis Project was dropped , leave behind nothing more than Carol Marcus ' unexplained absence inStar Trek Beyond .
Next : Why It ’s Good That William Shatner Does n’t Appear In Star Trek ’s Kelvin Timeline
