Grey’s Anatomy
Amelia Sheppard has returned toGrey ’s Anatomyfor the show ’s nineteenth season , which is presently bare new instalment on ABC on Thursday nights . The persona has experienced ups and downs , from losing her brother to overcoming her addiction , and fan have connected with Amelia through all of her plot line .
Amelia is one of the show ’s more popular and relatable characters , but a small group of the show ’s fans on Reddit does n’t always have well-disposed belief about the character . Some of these opinions do n’t resonate with long - meter spectator and Dame Muriel Spark heated debates about what way the writers should take her in .
Amelia’s Surgery
Heroic surgeries are a dime bag a dozen onGrey ’s Anatomy , so when both Sheppards were face with surgery that were considered high - risk , they were bound to be compared . Redditorjaggedjudgmentsaid , " Amelia ’s ' impossible ' surgical process on Herman was more inspiring and aroused than Derick ’s ' out of the question ' surgery on Isaac . "
While both surgery have been praised for their outcome and drama , Derek ’s patient was better have by audience and was seen as more sympathetic than Amelia ’s . The agency the case was present to Derek also had an impact since it bear witness a high level of reliance between fellow and how Issac saw Derek as a Redeemer .
Link’s Proposal
Many fans wanted to see Link and Amelia together and see Link ’s proposition asthe speculative thing to pass to their relationshipsince it led to their last breakup . Still , a diminished group of lover figure Amelia ’s choice to say no as the honest - pillowcase scenario . RedditorOk - Pop3069said Amelia was right to say no to Link ’s proposal . They explained , " If she pronounce yes , one of two thing would chance . 1 : Amelia would say yes , and they get get married and start becoming really toxic towards each other , or 2 : she suppose yes and ends up depart him at the altar . Either way , people would ’ve gotten anguish in the process , particularly Link . "
Most sports fan do n’t see this as how the kinship would end since they already have a nestling , and the show would have them be a happy mob . With this opinion being unpopular , it spotlight how romantic the fan base is and how they enjoy the happy ending plot line over the unhappy but practical ending .
Amelia and Kai
While the relationship showcased a new side of Amelia , fan were speedy to see how this relationship was another case of Amelia falling for someone who did n’t require the same things she want and was n’t unforced to compromise , just like with Link .
Derek’s Death
Derek Sheppard ’s episodes are some of the most importantGrey ’s Anatomylore , and his expiry was undoubtedly heart - wrenching on the show . watch Meredith deciding to remove him from life support had buff in shambles . Still , devotee were even more upset that she did n’t call Amelia before she made the choice . But Redditorblankpaper_said , " Meredith not call off Amelia before disconnect Derek was understandable , and she nonplus too much hatred for it . "
This opinion became unpopular because there is occasional evidence that Meredith deny Derek his give way wish with her actions . At one point , Derek say he want his babe around him if he is in a comatoseness , which he was , but Meredith does n’t call his menage to have them around . Even though the alternative came down to her , fans still felt it was incorrect of her not to contact his family .
Link And Amelia’s Relationship Is Overrated
Given the outcome of their family relationship , Redditors are conjecture season 19 ’s best storylinewill be a individual Amelia since she has experienced so much heartbreak , even though they love see her with Link , except Anow - delete Redditor , who read , " I do n’t think there is anything special about them , and they are overrate . "
This kinship resonates with fans since the character are so open about their need and take on the other ’s past with no hesitation , which is n’t something the show often does . In most casing , the character ’s past is used against them , as Owen did with Amelia when he used her past addiction to dishonor her current activity , but Link did n’t do this . Some fan still desire the pair will reconcile to farm Scout as husband and wife .
Owen Is Her Best Partner
buff ofGrey ’s Anatomyhave a complicated relationship with Owen , peculiarly regarding his kinship . Amelia and Owen were a pairing that most devotee were not happy about , except Redditorbrain_fried_over_med say , who say , " Owen and Amelia were definitely knotty , but Owen is the only guy Amelia has been with that is just as bang up as she is . "
This yoke is n’t liked because the character reference are too like to each other , and for the sentence they were developing a relationship , it was clear they require dissimilar thing and were too stubborn to find a compromise . Ultimately rooter believe they work better as Quaker since Amelia can be honest with Owen about things , like when she call in him out for holding a grudge against Teddy .
She’s Underrated As a Character On The Show
Much of Amelia ’s theatrical role was established on theGrey’sspin - offPrivate Practice , which impacted her character ’s reception on the main show . While a well deal of viewers like her , the reception Amelia receive from Redditors is not favorable , but RedditorSpiralSoursaid , " Amelia has her fault , but all in all , I think she ’s a near character . She really shines , specially in arch where she ’s tackling a adult case and overcome her ego - dubiety . "
The deficiency of Amelia ’s backstory being tied into the show has made the character seem less important than she is , making most viewers who discourse on-line dislike her and her action and liking her unpopular opinion .
She Is A Scapegoat
On the side of Reddit that does n’t like Amelia , she is often accused of stimulate her problems everyone else ’s before she leaves them because she has modify her mind about them and leaves the kinship . However , RedditorMawaruucontended this , saying , " everyone break to see that these graphic symbol are all the same manner - waltzing into everyone else ’s life and trauma dumping … but it ’s Amelia who ’s the whipping boy . The raunchiness of the character not getting a therapist is realistic , and the show would be nothing if everyone was all mentally - well … "
Amelia getting hate on-line show that some characters expect the brunt of a particular time of year ’s writing style . While the other characters are at error for sharing their hurt frequently , Amelia has been publish as someone who leave behind one kinship and receive into another immediately . This has created a cycle for the character that fans are no longer looking to see continue .
Her Character Makes People Stop Watching
Even the worst character ’s have n’t driven fans away fromGrey ’s Anatomy , which is part of why the show is still race after 19 seasons . But RedditorNorodiasaid , " I stopped watching two years ago because of her ; now I only follow the old episodes again and again . "
Fans have give too much time to atomic number 31 to give up on the show now , and time of year 15 was one ofthe beneficial seasons for Amelia ’s fictitious character , which made fan see her character more . This notion was largely unpopular because there are so many top side to the show for rooter , even if one character is bringing their viewing experience down .
She Says ‘Gaslight’ Too Much
Actors do n’t get to opt their lines , which most viewers recognize when they disagree with a show ’s negotiation , but that has n’t discontinue Redditors from sharing how much they dislike certain telephone line . Regarding Amelia , Redditorcelestialherculessaid , " It ’s like she learned the word ' gaslight ' and decided to use it in every argumentation . "
The Scripture gaslight has become popular vernacular for many people , even if it is misuse , which is the main argument here . However , using the term is n’t the character ’s defect but falls on the author , who fans have expressed frustration with lately .
Next:10 Best TV roommate
