Grey’s Anatomy
With the premiere of season 19 ofGrey ’s Anatomyjust around the corner on October 6 , some fans are speculating the return of " Dr. McDreamy " – Derek Shepherd . As the show ’s leading gentleman’s gentleman for a number of years , Shepherd has had a sight of intersecting and complex narratives that do n’t always patronise each other .
Whether it be Dr. Shepherd ’s puzzling adolescent long time or the infamous circumstances of his death , some fact surrounding Derek ’s history and his time on the show do n’t add up up . With the potential rejoinder of Sloan Grey ’s original heartthrob , it ’s prison term to take a look back at some of the biggest plot repugnance in Derek Shepherd ’s plot line .
Derek Cheating On Meredith In D.C.
Meredith and Derek ’s love life was testedtime and time again throughout their relationship . It ’s during Derek ’s time in D.C. that he meets inquiry dude Renee Collier , and she surprises him with a candy kiss . Even though Derek does pull away and immediately returns to Seattle to be with Meredith , he never tells her about this instant of unfaithfulness .
Related:16 Huge Plot Holes We Ca n’t Unsee On Grey ’s Anatomy
Although he most likely left this out in rescript to prevent any further difference in their human relationship , considering Derek ’s history of unfaithfulness in his marriage to Addison , this seems like a pretty great detail to not say Meredith . fan were divided over Derek ’s withholding of the osculation : some viewing audience believed it was the right call to preserve the relationship , while others decry his knavery and claimed it was unjust to Meredith .
Derek’s High School Years
Dr. Derek Shepherd was , without a uncertainty , Sloan Grey ’s main clotheshorse . In season two , fans were surprised when Shepherd shared that he was a " dorky ring kid " back in high school , an superannuated stereotype that probably would n’t fly today . However , Derek ’s teenaged year become a piffling perplexing in season 10 when he unwrap to Meredith that he accidentally paralyze someone while on the hockey team in high school .
Although it ’s not impossible for a student to be on the hockey team , as well as in the schooltime stria , it does sound a flake inconsistent with the individual he described himself as , as a child . Without having a exonerated film of who Derek was grow up , it ’s operose to read how his past has act upon his theatrical role in the series . These two backstories paint wildly different picture show of who Derek was in high school – was McDreamy just a nerdy band kid , an fast-growing jock , or something in between ?
Derek’s Car Accident
After witnessing a auto clangor on a back route with no cell service , Derek gets back in his car once the victims are taken by paramedical . Before he pulls aside , Derek is distracted by his phone ringing , and his motorcar is strike by a semi - truck .
This incident raised a mass of questions among sports fan . How was Derek ’s phone able-bodied to get a call even when it was made clear that this area is without jail cell armed service ? The stretch of road that he was stop on was relatively tacit and subject , so why did n’t Derek discover a semi - truck barrel towards his automobile ? It ’s questions like these that have caused fans to criticize the serial for not pay enough attention to detail for animportant persona ’s destruction like Shepherd ’s .
Derek’s Death
Derek ’s tragical last in time of year 11 is one of the more infamous inconsistencies in the serial publication . After being rush to the infirmary following his car accident , Derek inevitably dies due partially to neglect by the hand of his doctors and the infirmary being ill - equipped to take with his traumatic trauma .
AsDerek is a extremely skilled neurosurgeonfrom the Seattle area , it seems improbable that these doctors would n’t have know his importance in the field of medicine . If they had known who Derek was , they would have probably playact with a little more importunity , perchance pull through him from becoming brain - all in .
Derek’s Sisters
Once being declared wit - beat after his car accident , Meredith makes the decision to take Derek off of life support . But in the 2nd episode of the series , Derek say Meredith that if he is ever in a comatoseness , he would want his four sisters to be there with him . Meredith ostensibly go against this indirect request and take Derek off of life support without throw any of his sisters a luck to say their goodbyes .
Related:10 Jackson Avery Plot Holes That Make No Sense On Grey ’s Anatomy
Although the case could be made that it would take too longsighted to get all of his Sister to the hospital , Meredith could have at least call Derek ’s sister Amelia , who make for in the same building . Details like this have given rooter reason to call out the show for seemingly step on it Derek ’s death . As the show had surveil Derek Shepherd ’s life for its first 11 season , fans feel entitle to a more substantial ending for such an important and dear character reference .
Bailey Only Seems To Care About Derek & Meredith’s Relationship
At the source of the series , Bailey was warm to criticise Meredith for kip with Derek , and condemn their relationship as being unprofessional . But , this mental attitude does not seem to interpret to any of the other brace in the hospital .
When Cristina and Burke begin sleep with each other , Bailey does n’t seem to take any outcome with the pairing . When George and Callie obtain together , Bailey did n’t bat an eye . Some fans speculate that Bailey ’s rough treatment of Meredith is due to green-eyed monster stemming from Meredith ’s close kinship with Richard Webber . Bailey ’s high standard relate Meredith and Derek ’s relationship seems pretty discrepant compared to how she treats her other co - workers .
Derek & Mark’s Relationship
There ’s no doubt that Derek and Mark ’s bond is super deep ; growing up together the two were almost like Brother . However , when Derek ’s X - married woman Addison explains how she began to get to know Derek and Mark , she states that the three of them all became ally while they were in Medical schoolhouse in New York .
Although it ’s a small detail that many may have missed , Addison ’s statement fox Derek and Mark ’s family relationship into a tailspin . This oversight disenfranchises the pair ’s year spent together as child when they take shape their brother - like bond . Although their timeline may be a little muddled , it ’s certain that Derek and Mark have a long history .
Richard As Derek & Addison’s Mentor
Derek and Addison were first introduced to Richard Webber in medical shoal . Throughout their metre studying medical specialty in New York , Richard served as the mentor to both Derek and Addison , but this raises some questions . How is it that Derek and Addison were both able to be mentored by Richard ?
It seems pretty unrealistic that Richard could have been Derek and Addison ’s mentor , considering Richard is a cosmopolitan surgeon while Derek specialized in neurosurgery and Addison in Neonatal OR . If Derek and Addison had been mentor by specializer in their several fields , mayhap their lives never would have entwine the means that they had . Perhaps Shepherd could have still been unmarried by the sentence he meets Meredith at Sloan Grey , removing a large obstruction that stand up in the way of the start of their family relationship .
Richard & Mark Had Never Met
Richard was Derek ’s mentor throughout his time studying at Columbia . It ’s not until the three are turn together at Sloan Grey that Richard is present to Derek ’s best friend , Mark . However , this is n’t the first time that the three had been living together in the same city , as they all lived in New York when Derek and Mark were in aesculapian school .
Related:10 Plot Holes That Are n’t in reality Plot Holes On Grey ’s Anatomy
Fans have pointed out that it seems a little strange that throughout Mark and Derek ’s total meter in medical school that Mark and Richard never met . regard that Mark was like a brother to Derek and the skinny human relationship that Richard had to both Derek and his X - wife Addison , it feel unlikely that Richard and Mark ’s paths had never track during Mark ’s time in New York .
A Lot Of Dead Doctors
Throughout the series , dying is extremely common at Sloan Grey . Although some have pointed out that the death rate among patients is quite mellow , the amount of doctors who have died on the show also seems quite uncanny .
The causes of demise among the Sloan Grey Dr. range from electrocutions to plane crashes to getting hit by a bus . Fans have criticized the show for leaning on extremely dramatized deaths as a machine toeasily kill characters off ofGrey ’s Anatomy . Although the series has had its reasonable share of doctor expiry , the decease of Derek " McDreamy " Shepherd was definitely one of the hardest for fans to take in .
Next : Everything We Know About Grey ’s Anatomy Season 19
