Grey’s Anatomy
ERandGrey ’s Anatomywere on the air for about four geezerhood at the same time . For four years , aesculapian drama fans could look out Chicago on NBC and then switch to Seattle on ABC . Many medical dramatic play fans have and continue to savor more than one medical show on television set .
This twelvemonth , Grey ’s Anatomyjust outpacedER ’s 15seasons by beginning its 16th . But sometimes it ’s quality over quantity . Which show , in the end , is the ranking medical dramatic event ? It may be hard to resolve , but here are a few reasons to lie with one over the other .
ER - George Clooney
While Dr. McDreamy may have set a great deal of a show named after his eventual wife ( Meredith Grey ) , Patrick Dempsey still spend a good lot of clock time onGrey ’s Anatomynot doing medical things . He lived in a dawdler , wanted to marry Meredith , and he hang out at Joe ’s Bar .
Clooney ’s Dr. Doug Ross , on the other hand , partied off - screen ( as seen in the fender where he gets to process too soon to IV off a hangover ) but was working with patients the absolute majority of the time he was consider on the show . Even outside the emergency room , he was rescue teenagers from floods ( thus saving lives ) . The focus was on getting people good for you .
Grey’s Anatomy - Personal Drama
Grey ’s Anatomyhas often been compared to a soap opera house , but lives are like easy lay operas . Just because a person has a caper , or spends most of their time at work , does n’t signify that ’s all there is to them . ERspent most of its time actually in the ER ( romances took station on that show too , but not to the extent they did onGrey ’s ) .
Grey ’s Anatomyhighlighted a sight of the doctors as people , rather than doctors . It ’s part of what made the show place upright out from its first time of year , but it also helped to highlight the whole soul , rather than only the bandages when it came to medicinal drug .
ER - Case-Focused
It was always a surprisal whenERhad an episode that spend a lot of clip outside the pinch elbow room . The dramatic play materialize at the intake desk , or in the stave way , or in triage . Grey ’s Anatomy , on the other hand , saw the doctor visiting Meredith ’s home , sharing apartments , or going to league . SometimesGrey’sforgot all about the medicine .
fan got to lie with theERcharacters by how they border on their patients , not how they blab out about them after hour over beers . The show was named after the place where the medicine happened , and thus that ’s where the action mechanism always took place .
Grey’s Anatomy - Different Departments
While it is commendable thatERhad such a exculpated focus on the emergency department , medicinal drug is n’t all about stitch up blood and guts .
sure as shooting , the Dr. onGrey ’s Anatomyare training to be surgeons , but they also make trips to the pit , dermatology , and very frequently , the motherliness ward . At Grey Sloan Hospital , viewers are treated to quite a broad scene of medicine liken to what we see at County General .
ER - World Politics
Grey ’s Anatomymay have show the different departments in the infirmary , butERoffered a larger worldview on practice of medicine . From the news report of Kovac ’s losses in his menage country of Croatia , to his trip to serve save lives in Africa , ERhighlighted the different opportunity and struggle in treating patients in very dissimilar office of the world .
Grey ’s Anatomysent its doc around the country ( even guide to planer clangoring once ) but it did n’t add to the show ’s reach , only its dramatic art .
Grey’s Anatomy - Grow Up With The Characters
ERmay have see medical intern like Dr. Carter rise up the ranks , butGrey ’s Anatomyfocused ( in the beginning ) alone on a grouping of interns and the different tasks and challenges require to become a full - fledged medico and operating surgeon . For most of theERdoctors , fans took them as they were .
This is a side of medical specialty often discuss but seldom explore on TV . It have years of school and preparation to be successful andGrey ’s Anatomywanted to explore that battle , not just the competitiveness to carry through life .
ER - The Set
Very few hospitals get wind in film and on television look very much like the hospitals that regular hoi polloi impose every day . While the design vary wide in the substantial world , more people have check room similar to those seen at County General , than the clear , lustrous , and high tech Hall of Grey Sloan . ERhad the more realistic set , no questions asked .
Medical dramatic event , in general , do n’t get atrociously close to the veridical experience of exercise medicine , butERgot a little bit closer to the feel .
Grey’s Anatomy - Bailey
Bailey has been onGrey ’s Anatomysince its first season and there ’s a reasonableness . Besides the brilliant playing from Chandra Wilson , Bailey has always been the voice of truth on the show . Being a MD is hard . It lead clip and forfeiture , and Bailey has never been afraid to say so . While ER doctor advert around for quite a few seasons , the series stopping point left hardly anyone from the original cast .
She has never been afraid to say it loud and understandably to anyone who can try . She acknowledge a trueness that often gets missed when program normally heal affected role in less than the one - hour prison term slot .
ER - The Chaos
WhileGrey ’s Anatomyhas had more than its bonny plowshare of catastrophes ( see bombings , sinkings , shootings , make collapses , plane crashes),ERhighlighted the topsy-turvyness that existed in the emergency room on a unconstipated basis . ER , unlikeGrey’s , didn’t need the existence around them to collapse for it to sense that way .
Every new patient role could be its own disaster and it did n’t take the city implode on itself to made medicine a case of life or end . And for many patients who show up for ER medical attention , it can certainly feel like aliveness or end .
Grey’s Anatomy - The Music
It may seem like a dramatic license , but many surgeon , in fact , listen to music in the operating room ( surgerycan take quite a recollective time , after all ) . In that good sense , Grey ’s Anatomycould be a little more realistic thanER .
It certainly makes for compelling television , but it ’s also a petty turn of truth that the aesculapian community of interests has confirmed to their friend and loved ones . Sometimes medicine is its own medication .
NEXT : Grey ’s Anatomy : 10 Of Derek ’s Scariest Surgeries
